In Indiana, A Shelter Pup’s Adoption Ends In Heartbreak After Just One Day

By Brian Taylor 11/03/2025

For dogs living in shelters, adoption isn’t just a change of scenery, it’s everything. It’s the promise of love, safety, and belonging. So when that promise is broken, the pain runs deep.

Duke, affectionately nicknamed Meatball, learned this in the most painful way.

After being passed over time and again at the shelter in Indiana, this eighty-pound Terrier mix finally got his moment. He walked out of his kennel with his tail wagging and a wide smile, ready to begin a new life with a family of his own.

But within twenty-four hours, that dream was shattered.

A Second Chance That Didn’t Last


What makes Duke’s story even more heartbreaking is that this wasn’t the first time he’d been let down. He originally arrived at the DeKalb Humane Society in Indiana as a puppy and was adopted into what appeared to be a loving home.

For years, Duke lived the life every dog hopes for, until the day his family moved and left him behind.

“Duke’s been through it. He was adopted as a pup and raised in a home for years, only to be left behind when his people moved. He came to us heartbroken but hopeful,” the Indiana shelter wrote on Facebook.


Confused and alone, Duke was picked up as a stray and returned to DHS. This time, finding a new home proved much harder. While other dogs found families, Duke remained behind, waiting for someone to see him.

Eventually, a family came forward. It seemed like Duke’s long wait was finally over.

But the joy didn’t last.


On his first day in his new home, Duke slipped out of the backyard. Instead of working through the mishap, his adopters decided they weren’t the right match and returned him to the shelter.

“He was adopted again recently, but slipped away during a backyard oops and was sadly returned,” the shelter added.

For Duke, who struggled with the confinement of shelter life, the return was crushing. After just one day of freedom and affection, he was back behind the kennel door.

Still Holding Onto Hope For A Real Home


Duke’s path has been filled with setbacks. He knows there’s more to life than the walls of a shelter, and going back has been especially hard.

Yet, Duke hasn’t given up. His caregivers describe him as a loving, energetic dog who simply needs the right environment to thrive.

“Duke would do best with an active family who has the time to work with him on training and can provide a lot of love and exercise. A home without other pets would be ideal, where he can be the center of attention and continue to develop his social skills,” his caregivers explained.


Now six years old, Duke is healthy, neutered, vaccinated, and ready for adventure. He enjoys being around people, loves activity, and is eager to show he’s a loyal companion.

All he needs is a family willing to commit, to give him the stability and love he’s been waiting for.

Duke’s story is filled with heartbreak, but it’s also a testament to his resilience. With the right people, his next chapter could be the one that finally brings him peace.

Let’s hope this time, it’s forever.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *